Well, I suppose he is more expert at girls than I am, but it seems glaringly obvious to me that the UVA accusation was rape fantasy:
The story departs from realistic rape in numerous ways, and every departure is in the direction of female rape fantasies. That the students are high status fits political fantasies. The broken glass, and a whole pile of them sharing one girl, fits only female sex fantasies.
Men having sex with a girl amidst broken glass is an obvious female fantasy. Gang rape by absurdly many high status males is an obvious female fantasy. If I told you I had sex with the Swedish beach bikini volleyball team, would you believe me?
She is not raped by some random low status male, but by a whole team of the very highest status males in her social circle. Instead of being on the booty call rotation of one high status male with thirty other women, she has more than half a dozen of them all to herself.
And they are so frantically eager to rape her that they get down in the broken glass.
And they rape her for three hours, which works out at twenty two minutes per student. The typical university student is lighting a joint after a couple of minutes. The performance of these rapists tell me she has watched too many porn movies.
Now I can easily imagine that if the girl is in broken glass while being raped that might well make it more fun for the rapist, and more fun for her, but if the guy is in broken glass also – that is going to make it a lot more fun for her, but considerably less fun for him.
No highly attractive high status guy is going to share a girl with half a dozen other highly attractive high status guys, and if I was going to rape a girl for twenty minutes, would first turn on the light, get out a broom, and correctly position all the broken glass. In fact, if going to have sex for twenty minutes, going to do it on a comfortable bed, and find some other more precisely controllable fun way of inflicting fun amounts of pain, such as a spanking. Broken glass implies frantic eagerness, which frantic eagerness does not fit with twenty minutes per rapist, nor does frantic eagerness fit with high status highly attractive guys having sex. The story in unreal in ways that provide the teller with the maximum sexual arousal.
Her being down in the broken glass makes sense if she is telling a political tale about cis heteronormative rape patriarchal oppression, but the oppressors being down in the broken glass only makes sense as getting her off sexually.
Obviously the reason this appeared in Rolling Stone rather than a slash fiction is political, not sexual – UVA wants to shut down the fraternities. But “Jackie”, the woman that composed it, and continues to claim it is true, was enthusiastically beating her pussy while she composed it.
Fake rape accusations featuring real people ruin lives. The women that do this need to be destroyed. “Jackie” needs to be identified.